Sunday, April 15, 2012

The Allegory of the Cave: Truth v. Reality


The Allegory of the Cave speaks directly to truth and reality. Socrates is teaching Glaucon about the ignorance people live in and the difficulty of learning the truth. According to his allegory, Socrates compares it to the pain of sunlight hitting your eyes once you leave the darkness of the cave. In the end the truth is worthwhile, but it takes time to adjust to, as Socrates explains, “And first he will see the shadows best, next the reflections of men and other objects in the water, and then the objects themselves…” The Allegory creates a division between reality and truth, what I take away from Socrates lesson is that they are not on in the same. A reality is what surrounds you and is what you believe. The dark cave where the chained men are is a reality. Although to the student it is clear the shadows are not real, rather illusions to the chained men they are the truth because it is all they see and all they can believe in, therefore making it a reality. In the allegory, the truth or the light removes the student from this reality. The reality is broken apart by the truth because when a man is free from the chains and darkness by seeing and adjusting to the light he is then able to see the shadows were just illusions and can now see and even touch the real thing. In the case of the allegory, reality and truth are different because reality is not necessarily true it is what one takes away from their surroundings whereas the truth can break apart this reality by showing what is false about it, therefore creating a new reality.